Published: | Last Updated: November 4, 2026

Pressed for time? Listen to a summary of this blog
At a Glance
• Some taxpayers who filed refund, protective, or abatement claims based on Kwong v. United States have received letters from the IRS denying their claims. If you received one of these letters, do not ignore it but don't assume it necessarily ends the matter either.
• Kwong involves complex questions about the effect of IRC § 7508A(d) on certain tax deadlines during the COVID-19 federal disaster period. The government has appealed the decision, and the litigation is continuing. A recent district court decision, Singh v. United States, addressed some of these same issues in a case involving an earlier tax year.
• Taxpayers need to understand what an IRS letter declining to process or denying a claim means, what it may not mean, and what steps they should consider taking now to protect their rights while the litigation continues.
• The answer may be different depending on several factors, including (1) whether you have already paid the penalty or interest at issue or whether the amount remains unpaid and (2) whether the IRS has sent you a formal notice of claim disallowance as opposed to an administrative letter denying or rejecting your claim.
• Pay particular attention to deadlines. A statutory notice of claim disallowance generally starts a two-year period for filing a refund suit. Continuing to communicate with the IRS or requesting reconsideration generally does not stop that clock.
Why I Am Writing About This Now
Over the past six months, I have written about Kwong and encouraged potentially affected taxpayers to consider filing refund or protective claims to preserve their rights while the legal issues are being resolved. Because statutory deadlines continued to run while the courts considered these issues, most taxpayers affected by Kwong generally needed to act by July 10, 2026, to preserve claims that otherwise would have expired based on the court's interpretation. Other taxpayers may have different deadlines because their refund statutes remain open, so July 10, 2026, was not necessarily the deadline for every taxpayer or every claim.
Some taxpayers followed that advice. Since that time, the IRS has received more than 275,000 Forms 843, Claim for Refund and Request for Abatement, asserting Kwong-related claims. That’s a substantial number, but it represents only a small fraction of the tens of millions of taxpayers that could have been impacted by the Kwong litigation.
It is also important to recognize the taxpayers we may never hear from. Some potentially affected taxpayers may not have known about the July 10, 2026, deadline, may not have understood that they needed to file a claim to preserve their potential rights, or may have found the procedures too difficult to navigate without professional assistance. Others may have determined they were not eligible or simply chosen not to file. Whatever the reason, the significant difference between the potentially affected population and the number of claims filed underscores why clear, timely, and understandable IRS guidance matters.
IRS correspondence has real consequences for taxpayer behavior. A taxpayer who receives a letter saying a claim has been denied may understandably conclude: “That's it. I lost.” That may cause the taxpayer to stop pursuing the claim, miss a deadline, pay an amount the taxpayer was disputing, or believe that filing a lawsuit is the only way to preserve their rights.
The procedural picture may be more complicated.
First, Understand What You Received
If you received an IRS letter concerning a Kwong-related claim, start by reading it carefully and keeping a copy. Different IRS communications can have very different legal consequences. One of the most important distinctions is whether the IRS issued a statutory notice of claim disallowance under IRC § 6532(a). The IRS commonly uses Letter 105C to fully disallow a refund claim and Letter 106C to partially disallow a claim. When the IRS mails a statutory notice of claim disallowance by certified or registered mail, the taxpayer generally has two years from the date the notice is mailed to file a refund suit. A taxpayer also may waive the statutory notice, which can affect when the period begins.
Importantly, the law does not require the IRS to use a particular letter or form, and a notice does not necessarily have to expressly state the two-year deadline to start that period. What matters is whether the correspondence adequately communicates a final disallowance and satisfies the applicable legal requirements. Conversely, correspondence merely stating that the IRS will not process a claim, requesting additional information, or proposing a future disallowance may not constitute a statutory notice of claim disallowance.
But don't guess.
If you are uncertain what type of notice you received or whether it has started a legal deadline, consider consulting a qualified tax professional. This is especially important once the letter is approaching its two-year anniversary.
What If My Claim Involves a Tax Year Before January 20, 2020?
Some taxpayers have received correspondence denying Kwong-related claims involving tax years before the beginning of the COVID-19 disaster period. A recent decision illustrates why taxpayers receiving these letters need clear procedural guidance.
In Singh v. United States, No. 1:25-cv-00056 (E.D.N.Y. Sept. 24, 2026), the taxpayer's refund claim involved her 2017 federal income tax return. The district court denied the government's motion to dismiss and concluded, on the facts before it, that her refund claim was timely, allowing the case to proceed. The court did not determine whether the taxpayer ultimately was entitled to a refund.
The court reached that conclusion on two separate grounds. First, it held that an earlier letter Ms. Singh sent to the IRS constituted an informal refund claim that she later perfected by filing an amended return. Second, it addressed the application of IRC § 7508A(d) to the limitations period applicable to her claim. The Singh decision does not end the Kwong litigation, nor does it mean every claim involving an earlier tax year is timely. Refund statutes are highly fact-specific. Filing dates, payment dates, prior correspondence, the type of tax or penalty involved, and other facts can all matter.
For taxpayers, the important point is simpler: If you received a letter denying your claim or stating that the IRS cannot process your claim, preserve your records and understand your procedural rights and deadlines before deciding what to do next.
Scenario One: You Already Paid the Amount and Filed a Refund or Protective Claim
If you already paid the penalty or interest and filed a refund or protective claim, keep:
- The IRS letter you received;
- Your original refund or protective claim;
- Any Form 843 or Form 1040-X you submitted;
- Proof of when and how you filed it;
- Proof of payment;
- Certified-mail receipts or electronic submission confirmations; and
- All other correspondence with the IRS.
You should also determine whether the IRS correspondence you received constitutes a formal notice of claim disallowance. This is important because a formal notice can start the clock for filing a refund suit. If the two-year period under IRC § 6532(a) has begun, asking the IRS to reconsider your claim generally does not stop that clock. Do not assume that continued correspondence with the IRS automatically extends your deadline.
This deadline has important consequences. If the two-year period expires without a timely refund suit or a valid extension, taxpayers may lose their ability to obtain a refund. Continuing to work with the IRS or requesting reconsideration generally does not preserve that right. That is why understanding what type of IRS letter you received and whether it triggered the two-year period is so important.
The bottom line: Know what letter you received and what deadline, if any, it triggered.
A Possible Future Option: Extending the Two-Year Period
In Certain Circumstances There May Be Another Option: Extending the Two-Year Period
If the IRS has issued a statutory notice of claim disallowance, IRC § 6532(a)(2) permits the IRS and taxpayer to agree in writing to extend the two-year period for filing a refund suit. The IRS generally uses Form 907, Agreement to Extend the Time to Bring Suit, for this purpose.
An extension may provide additional time for the IRS to reconsider a claim or for related litigation to develop without requiring the taxpayer to immediately file a lawsuit. However, an extension is not automatic. Both the taxpayer and IRS must agree, and the agreement generally must be executed before the existing deadline expires. Taxpayers should not assume requesting reconsideration or pursuing an administrative appeal protects their rights unless an extension has actually been executed. As this extension authority applies prospectively, it may not be procedurally available for current Kwong related claims. Taxpayers should follow the Kwong litigation and consult current IRS guidance or a qualified tax professional regarding its availability.
Taxpayers generally may file a refund suit once the IRS disallows the claim or, if the IRS has not acted, after six months have passed since the claim was filed, assuming the taxpayer has satisfied the other requirements for bringing a refund suit. But the fact that a taxpayer may file suit does not necessarily mean that immediately filing one is the best course of action, which is where an extension of time to bring a refund suit may be a better option, if the IRS consents.
Scenario Two: You Asked the IRS to Abate Penalties or Interest You Have Not Paid
A second group of taxpayers is in a very different position. Some taxpayers filed Form 843 asking the IRS to abate penalties or interest that had been assessed but had not yet been paid, and the IRS declined to process those requests.
If this happened to you, remember that an abatement request involving an unpaid assessment is different from a refund claim for an amount you have already paid. That distinction matters.
If the disputed penalty or interest remains unpaid, you may still have procedural options while the Kwong litigation continues. Depending on your circumstances, you may be able to request that the IRS delay or suspend certain collection activity while the issue is being resolved. Assuming the courts do not sustain the Kwong decision, interest continues to accrue while the litigation is pending.
Do not simply ignore collection notices. Collection procedures have their own deadlines and protections, and failing to respond can have consequences including increased interest due. If the legal landscape later changes, a taxpayer with an unpaid assessment may also have an opportunity to submit another request for abatement.
What If I Pay the Penalty or Interest While the Litigation Continues?
Payment can change the procedural posture. Once a taxpayer pays an assessed penalty or interest, the taxpayer may be able to file a claim seeking a refund of that payment. IRC § 6511 contains the limitations periods governing refund claims. Generally, a taxpayer has three years from the date the return was filed or two years from the date the tax was paid, whichever period expires later, to file a refund claim. Separate rules under § 6511 also limit the amount that may be refunded based on when the payment was made and when the refund claim was filed. For taxpayers seeking a refund of a penalty or interest paid after an earlier request for abatement was denied, the two-year period measured from the date of payment may provide an important opportunity to file a refund claim.
So if you pay an amount that was the subject of an earlier abatement request, keep careful records of exactly when and how much you paid. Do not assume that the IRS's earlier denial of your abatement request necessarily determines whether you can later file a refund claim after making a payment. But do not assume you have unlimited time either.
What Should Taxpayers Do Now?
If you received an IRS letter declining to process or denying a Kwong-related refund, protective, or abatement claim:
- Keep the letter and all of your records. Save your claim, proof of filing, and all IRS correspondence.
- Determine whether the disputed amount has been paid. This is important because the procedures for an unpaid abatement request and a paid refund claim are different.
- Identify exactly what type of IRS letter you received. Determine whether it is a formal notice of claim disallowance or another type of IRS correspondence such as declining to process or no consideration.
- Pay attention to every deadline. This includes refund claim deadlines, refund suit deadlines, and any deadlines contained in collection notices.
- Do not assume continued IRS consideration stops a statutory deadline. Requesting reconsideration or pursuing an administrative appeal generally does not stop the two-year period after a statutory notice of claim disallowance is issued.
- Do not ignore collection notices if the amount remains unpaid. Collection notices have their own deadlines and procedural protections. Depending on your circumstances, you may be able to request that the IRS delay certain collection activity while the legal issues continue to be resolved. If your deadline may be approaching, consider obtaining professional advice.
- Consider whether an extension of the refund suit period is appropriate. If you received a statutory notice of claim disallowance, IRC §6532(a)(2) permits the IRS and the taxpayer to agree in writing to extend the period for filing a refund suit, generally using Form 907. An extension is not automatic and must be executed before the applicable deadline expires.
If you later pay disputed penalties or interest, consider filing a refund or protective claim. Payment may create an opportunity to seek a refund even if the IRS previously denied your request for abatement. Under IRC §6511, taxpayers generally have three years from filing the return or two years from payment, whichever period expires later, to file a refund claim, subject to the applicable statutory limitations. If you are relying on the two-year-from-payment rule, generally you must file your claim within two years after that payment. Keep documentation showing the date and amount of each payment and copies of any claims you file.
What I Am Asking the IRS to Do
My concern is straightforward: Taxpayers should receive clear information that allows them to make informed decisions and protect their rights while these legal issues remain unresolved. Congress has already recognized the importance of explaining refund denials. IRC § 6402(l) requires the IRS to provide taxpayers with an explanation when it disallows a refund claim. Yet an inadequate explanation does not necessarily prevent a notice from starting the two-year period for filing suit. That creates a serious concern when taxpayers receive correspondence denying claims involving unsettled legal questions.
Taxpayers should not have to decipher complicated procedural rules or consult an attorney simply to understand what the IRS has decided, why it reached that conclusion, and what steps they must take to preserve their rights. That is fundamental to the taxpayer Right to Be Informed.
I am particularly concerned that the IRS is sending letters to some taxpayers declining to process or disallowing their Kwong-related claims based on criteria that may not adequately account for the legal issues still being litigated. These letters can have significant consequences. Taxpayers may mistakenly believe their claims have no merit, abandon their efforts to obtain relief, or face unnecessary litigation to preserve their rights.
I have asked the IRS to identify taxpayers who received these letters, review the determinations, and take appropriate corrective action. Equally important, I urge the IRS to review and update its guidance and claim-screening criteria before issuing additional Kwong-related denial or no-consideration letters. The IRS should ensure that employees are applying consistent procedures that properly account for the unresolved legal questions, including claims involving tax years preceding the COVID-19 disaster period.
I believe the better approach is to hold the claims until the courts have finally resolved the underlying legal issues. This approach is consistent with the IRS's own guidance. IRM 25.6.1.10.3.2.5(3) recognizes that, in general, delaying action on protective claims until pending litigation is resolved serves the interests of both taxpayers and the IRS. Once the litigation is resolved, the IRS can evaluate the claims under the applicable law and determine whether additional information is needed before allowing or disallowing them.
Holding these claims would help protect taxpayers from prematurely losing their rights, reduce confusion, and avoid forcing taxpayers into unnecessary litigation while the courts determine the law. It would also allow the IRS to conserve resources and apply the final legal determination consistently to affected taxpayers.
For any correspondence the IRS determines is necessary while the litigation continues, taxpayers should receive clear explanations of:
- The nature and effect of the IRS's determination;
- Why the claim was denied or not processed;
- What deadlines, if any, the taxpayer must protect;
- What administrative options may remain available;
- Whether the taxpayer may request an extension of the period for filing suit;
- What options may remain available to taxpayers with unpaid assessments; and
- What taxpayers should do while the litigation continues.
Where prior correspondence may have left taxpayers with an incomplete or inaccurate understanding of their procedural rights, the IRS should provide additional clarification and, where appropriate, take corrective action.
Taxpayers who took timely steps to preserve their rights should not be placed at risk of losing those rights because the IRS prematurely denied or declined to process their claims while the controlling legal questions remain unresolved.
Avoiding Unnecessary Litigation
More fundamentally, I encourage the IRS to consider whether it is necessary to issue disallowance notices on refund or protective claims while the underlying legal questions remain unresolved.
Taxpayers filed protective claims to preserve their rights while the courts determine the law. Issuing final disallowances may start statutory deadlines that eventually force taxpayers to consider filing refund suits simply to keep those rights alive.
Where legally permissible, holding protective claims pending resolution of the litigation or establishing a consistent process for considering requests to extend the period for filing suit under IRC § 6532(a)(2) could protect taxpayer rights while reducing unnecessary litigation and conserving resources for taxpayers, the IRS, and the Department of Justice.
I am particularly concerned about taxpayers who may read a denial letter and unnecessarily abandon a potential claim or, on the other extreme, conclude that they must immediately file a federal lawsuit to preserve their rights. Neither taxpayers nor the government benefit from unnecessary confusion or litigation.
Conclusion: Taxpayer Rights Should Not Get Lost in the Litigation
Kwong presents legal issues that the courts are continuing to consider. The government and taxpayers will make their arguments, and the courts will ultimately determine the law. My role as National Taxpayer Advocate is different. My focus is making sure taxpayers do not inadvertently lose their rights while that process plays out.
A taxpayer who receives an IRS letter should be able to understand what the IRS decided, why it made that decision, what options remain available, and what deadline comes next. That is especially important when the underlying legal issue is still being litigated.
TAS will continue working with the IRS to identify affected taxpayers, clarify the effect of the correspondence they received, and provide taxpayers with practical information about the steps they can take to preserve their rights while the courts resolve these issues.
The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the National Taxpayer Advocate. The National Taxpayer Advocate presents an independent taxpayer perspective that does not necessarily reflect the position of the IRS, the Treasury Department, or the Office of Management and Budget. NTA Blog posts are generally not updated after publication. Posts are accurate as of the original publication date. Portions of this blog may have been developed with the assistance of artificial intelligence. All AI-assisted content has been reviewed, verified, and approved by the National Taxpayer Advocate or TAS staff to ensure accuracy and integrity.
